Mana12The Greens are soft on National:

Last week, Russel Norman and Gareth Hughes made much of the Greens’ ability to deliver no matter who is in Government.

Why would they do this? Because they have lost faith in the left – the core of which is still the urban working class – and are trying to broaden their appeal to appeal to voters from the leafy suburbs of Epsom, Khandallah, Fendalton etc, to appeal to natural National voters. Last election the Greens took over 10% of the vote in wealthy Epsom and Ilam; they got just 3% in working-class Mangere. A prominent election promise of theirs is to cut the company tax rate!

Why does this matter? In elections, politicians and voters often lose sight of the fact that it is not about policy – it is about a struggle for power. In a fight, it matters which side you are on.

The Greens are soft on the causes of National

On the left, many of the Greens policies act as a positive force. In alliance with the right, the same policies – on climate change, for examples – become excuses for austerity. Their inability to commit to the left is a real weakness. They always want to play both sides. Norman recently claimed to be more free market than the Nats. If he had limited himself to expose the Nats’ free market rhetoric as hypocrisy that would be good. But he genuinely wants to be accepted as respectable by free market economists. That is disastrous.

The free market system is what created John Key, millionaire currency trader, and his corrupt crew. The free market system is fundamentally opposed to democracy. [Read More...]

Recent articles

Love NZ

Foreigners are not to blame: nationalism and the elections

While the fall-out from Nicky Hager’s Dirty Politics is the standout feature of the general election campaign, some of the foremost policy questions have been around the interrelated issues of housing, land ownership, and immigration. Labour, Green and Internet Mana have taken a nationalist, anti-foreigner stand alongside New Zealand First, who claim this territory as their own. […]


Prison reform on the path to prison abolition

[Activist Olive McRae submitted this article to Socialist Review, and we were happy to print it in our latest issue. National’s announcement last week of more plans for ‘working prisons’ gives the article an added relevance and urgency. You can subscribe to Socialist Review here.] “Those of us that identify as prison abolitionists as opposed […]


March Against New Zealand’s Shame

600 – 700 people marched against domestic violence, ending at parliament, today. The march was a uniting call to action to address sexual and domestic violence. There were other protests on this issue throughout the country, with the one at parliament the largest by far. The Facebook page for the event described it as follows: […]

Love NZ

Are the Greens a Left Alternative?

Brian S. Roper takes an in-depth look at the policies and politics of the Greens.   Introduction As indicated by the major polls, support for the Green Party ranged from around 11% to 13% throughout 2014. The Green Party received 11% of the vote and 14 MPs at the 2011 general election, compared to Labour’s […]


Nicky Hager Q&A on “Dirty Politics”

Nicky Hager’s book “Dirty Politics” has captured the headlines since it was released and has rocked this election campaign. At a recent public meeting in Auckland, Nicky Hager engaged with the public answering questions and explaining the ethos behind the book and how he came to write it. Josh O’Sullivan was there. It was an […]

The Second Leaders Debate: A Response to Key on Capital Gains Tax

The media has proclaimed John Key the winner of last night leaders’ debate  because Labour leader David Cunliffe was caught off guard by Key’s question as to whether his proposed capital gains tax would apply to “300,000 family homes held in trusts”. Given that Key made over $5 million dollars in tax-free capital gains last […]


Ballot for industrial action by PSA members in the health sector

Over the first few days of August, a secret ballot for industrial action was conducted by Public Service Association (PSA) members in the health sector. The result was a resounding yes to industrial action. More than one third of the 12,000 PSA health members participated in the on-line ballot with 90% voting in favour. Allied […]

We Need Independent Class Politics, Not Cross-class Alliances

[In June we published an editorial 'Should Socialists Support the Internet-Mana alliance?' Martin Gregory from our Wellington/Poneke branch replied here. In this contribution Shomi Yoon continues the debate. This article was submitted before Nicky Hager's Dirty Politics was published.] The latest polls show National in a comfortable lead with Labour trailing woefully behind. If the […]

From the archive

Anzac Day: Against the Carnival of Reaction

mobiliseagainstthewarOn Anzac Day 1967, at the height of New Zealand involvement in the ‘American War’ in Vietnam, with New Zealand troops taking part in the suppression of the Vietnamese struggle for national liberation, members of the Progressive Youth Movement in Christchurch tried to lay a wreath following the dawn service in memory of those killed by imperialism in Vietnam. They were arrested and charged with disorderly behaviour. Feminists a decade later faced down a media-driven public outcry when they laid wreaths to the victims of sexual violence during war.

Lest we forget? It’s more like lest we remember. Anzac Day serves as a carnival of nationalist reaction, a day of public ritual aimed at promoting forgetting: forgetting the real legacy of New Zealand imperialism and militarism in favour of a sentimental nationalism, an anti-political celebration of national unity. [Read More...]


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 51 other followers